Reviews / Sinner

Share Manga with...
Share Manga with...
OriginalOtaku
Love it Asaya x mitsui
Jan 11
thumb_up 0
SpurgeonJonathan
think what wil happen to the dinamic duo will they get to gether or will they hate each others guts after this war!!!!!!
Sep 27
thumb_up 1
BeBop43-24
I've read it twice now, the emotion is strong and deep and the story's surreal.
Mar 29
thumb_up 0
Not Cake
Awesome, but rip the cliffhanger.
Mar 28
thumb_up 3
.Kamilė
I love it, but... it has been over a year now. Where are other parts?
Mar 03
thumb_up 5
RubinNoah
Pyscho Pass.......
Feb 24
thumb_up 0
axemen31502
Bello!
Spero che continui presto!
Dec 05
thumb_up 1
Chilling
When does new chapters come out? Cause I read this majority in one night about a month ago, forgot about it, and remembered it checked up and still no knew chapters.
Nov 02
thumb_up 300
27MKJE
It gives off a dystopic vibe of our current society, where in we are judged by our backgrounds and traits and not by our true nature. It is society that forces us to become who we are. Some see the "cake" as a happy ending for them, it give an acute pleasure of sweetness but it's also a coward escape to society's cave*.
*Plato's Cave Allegory
Oct 22
thumb_up 4
deraeg13
Awesome story and art, transitions in story are a bit jarring- but it's more a storytelling trait than a flaw.
Oct 06
thumb_up 5
BakaNekoV1
Great story so far
Oct 04
thumb_up 6
AkimotoKirigaya
I love this manga
Sometime I think the world is better without "sinner" and maybe world will become better without them so, but world without sin is just a world of lie system that we can't have our free will
Oct 02
thumb_up 21
Đăng LinhHà
it's surprisingly good, the base story is good, the development feels full of random thought from the author. At first glance it seems like it's trying to uncover the past of the protagonists in a pushy way, but at the same time it feels like just a collection of short stories that the mangaka randomly writes out without any purpose whatsoever. Its a dark story written in doraemon style, its weird but I like it.

I don't know how long its has been suspended but I hope it can continue soon, I feel the manga is gonna end around chapter 20 though. He probably told everything he wanted to tell us, just need to wrap it up with a good ending.
Oct 02
thumb_up 5
cichlid87
I've just read a couple chapters but it's interesting so far.
Sep 03
thumb_up 5
Wide-eyed Wander
I find the plot really intriguing & fascinated for of the conflict that could occur. It's quite an action packed manga that really makes you think. It dives into a mind of a society that predetermines whether their people that evil. It reminds me of the church preaching that babies are born from the sins of the humans before us like adam & eve but we find salvation from Jesus. It's kinda fucked up to be constantly reminded that we are filthy sinners.
Aug 25
thumb_up 7
MadamManga
Really great manga. Good art style and plot. I love alternate, dystopian societies. I recommend to those who enjoyed Hunger Games and Divergent.
Aug 25
thumb_up 34
Buraku
I've only read six chapters, but it's pretty good so far! I love the characters and it has its surprising moments! Only wish there was more action and a bit of romance. Other than that, I recommend reading this!
Aug 25
thumb_up 6
Ccv
Have only read 5 chapters so far. It has nice drawing and is easy to follow. I feel it may be moving a bit fast as we quickly learn things about characters. Have not gotten far enough to determine the way the manga will continue, but as of right now it is ok and is worth a read to get a feel for the plot and characters.
Aug 24
thumb_up 1010
Lirasity
A manga set in a utopian society which explores the perspective of those who view it as a dystopia.
The art style really emphasizes the gruesome reality of such a society. The story moves rather quickly, but does a good job of capturing interest while maintaining momentum. Worth a read if you're interested in dystopian novels with a side of action.
Aug 23
thumb_up 8
sojisgreat
I am really loving this manga. The drawing and art type is amazing! The plot gets more interesting every chapter!
Aug 23
thumb_up 0
gnomy35
After having read five chapters it's a pretty interesting manga. There's action and emotion, and the art is stylish if unpolished. But things go way too fast and we still don't know anything about the main character aside from where he comes from. I hope the rest will go more slowly so I can get more invested in what's happening.
Aug 23
thumb_up 0
DarkNova
Is sin imprinted on our DNA? Do our birth conditions determine whether we become criminals or good citizens? These are just some of the questions this manga tells about. Dark and philosophical, the story is shocking from the very first chapter. It's definitely worth following.
Aug 23
thumb_up 0
Justin Andrew Mason
Dark. Gritty. And, with a focus on how quickly and easily a "civilized" society can descend into fascism. I find the protagonists immediately likeable, even if at times I question their morality. This manga borrows heavily from well trodden themes in the science fiction dystopian genre, but presents them in a way that's different enough to be interesting. Really great art. Vive la résistance!
Aug 22
thumb_up 0
Acrophobe
A great manga that asks many important philosophical and moral questions. The characters have interesting backstories. It's a heavy and dark subject matter, but as our society changes we need to ask ourselves lots of hard questions that this manga wants you to think about.

Definitely worth reading, even if only to remind people that no matter what side, we all are human and don't deserve to be treated badly.
Aug 22
thumb_up 0
domokunrawr
I would have to say that this manga so far has been more entertaining than I had originally thought it was going to be. The overall premise and a different take on a dystopia creates interesting characters and relates to a nature and nurture situation. The story skips around sometimes and makes the flow of the manga a bit jarring at times but definitely would binge read these on occasion.
Aug 22
thumb_up 0
sharkshocker
Nice art and interesting concept, not sure where the story will lead yet but there's potential for character growth since they'll all have different histories.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
Marvin Ortega
A good manga about trying to create utopias in a real world
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
pvogt1990
up to chapter 4. the story paints a very dark and complex setting. the characters are somewhat interesting. all in all a good read
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
kashaunleak
Chapter 1 sets up the way their world works in a very brief few pages, getting you right into the story without much going on or flooding you with a ton of characters to remember. The two main protagonists are introduced and a hint at what the two are planning without exactly exemplifying what those plans are quite yet.
The author of the manga and the artist do very well in conveying the story with a decent amount of detail in the artwork and with clear flow in the dialogues. I'm going to keep reading, and see where this takes me.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
Rachel751
This is my favorite manga out of all of the manga. It is really intresting and great character design.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
animupepper
It has an interesting premise with a dystopian society. I really like the art style, with moments of funny versions of the character design for silly parts and reactions. I have read four chapters so I can't say much about how i feel about the story, but i think it was picking up by chapters 3 and 4. It is quick to read, and am interested to reading more of it to see where it goes.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
Money-san
Original story and great character design
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
SpicyMayonnaise
If there were a 10 point scale I would rate this at a 6, above average. This manga is very easy to get into and is also quite interesting but of course has its flaws. The premise around the main characters is very simple the author does a great job at writing a manga that is both interesting and easy to follow. The only downside is that the story is quite one dimensional and easily predictable. I personally don't mind this for the most part, but I'd prefer a manga that is less predictable.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
Robert
Interesting setting where society determines a persons worth at birth. The heroes are "sinners", born criminals, guerilla insurgents who fight to overthrow the cruel government.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
muffyneng
Decent art, average story.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
alexavier
While the premise of this manga is not completely original, it does have imagination and an interesting concept - similar to Minority Report but with it's own unique twist . However, the characters aren't fleshed out very well and they quickly become unrelatable and generic. The story jumps timelines which would've help fleshed out a more interesting world and characters but the execution is confusing at times. I really feel this Manga would've greatly benefited from having more developed characters and a better understanding of their motivations, I understood the suffering they endured but struggled to understand what exactly drove them and to what end goal.
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
Alpa~CHINO
Creating new and intriguing Action/Thriller manga is not an easy task, and sadly, Kye's Sinner leaves a lot to be desired. As others have written, the mangaka seems to be passionate about his work, but the writing is pretty average, the rebels don't truly have a clear goal, and characters are not developed enough. The pacing is not fast enough in certain chapters for an Action manga, and some small story bits are drawn out too much instead of moving the story forward, like...

*Minor Spoiler*
The Gender chapter... I mean, just from the cover alone, I think it's clear Mitsui is a 17 years old tomboyish female. If she was drawn more masculine or ambiguous, it would make more sense for Asaya and the others to mistake her for a boy. Apart from a bit of comic relief, was 40 pages really necessary for this chapter as the way it was written?
*Minor Spoiler End*

We have not yet reached the big finale yet, but I don't think it will save the story. I do believe, however, that with its initial p
Aug 21
thumb_up 0
A.R.
I like the concept and the chapters about the Strawberry Sponge Cake Man, but I thought everything else is meh for me. I found the plot and the main characters to be shallow. The story tries to be meaningful by showing how the Sinner system works and how it affects the characters. But the attempts fell flat for me due to how ham-fisted the writing becomes when it shows off how horrible life is for the sinners. I also found the story to slightly confusing at times. The main characters are the rebel with a cause, but the writing doesn't make it clear what exactly are their goals are and how they want to achieve them.

I'm sad to say that I didn't like this work.
Aug 20
thumb_up 0
dalli
(Just 4 chapters read, keep this in mind while reading this review)
This manga has its premise heavily based in the "nurture vs nature" long debate, but it tackles in a shallow way, turning the central characters just some kind of "rebels against the system" - which they are, of course - but we don't relate to them, don't cheer for them, don't even know what they want (fight to change the law? pursue a safe place to live? to rescue the ones locked up? to destroy the government out of spite? I don't know, and don't find myself caring
The focus on the characters is most for exposition and leaves a forced development feel, with some hardened-looking characters having a huge emotional breakdown with half-assed provoking, just for another throw some kind of deep speech and catchphrases.
(yeah bro, in her 15-ish years living she never thought how miserable her life is, of course).
Aug 19
thumb_up 0
Daniel McBride
Sinner, as a manga, I would say is about average in the genre, but after reading what is released (16 chapters) and reflecting on it, you can feel the passion the author has for the world they created. All in all, not the best one out there, but definitely worth giving a shot.
Aug 17
thumb_up 0
Terence
I like the design of characters while the story is kinda edgy & interesting
Aug 17
thumb_up 0
Mint
Notice: this manga is still currently being published at the time of this review!

The story of Sinner shows some interesting potential, showcasing a pretty gruesome and gritty world. Unfortunately the characters currently have had shallow backgrounds generic to this genre, and there isn't much content for me to truly get hooked into reading this manga(16 chapters so far!)

Maybe read it if you've time on your hands, if not, wait till more chapters are published.
Aug 15
thumb_up 0
krdenjo
Interesting manga with a serious topic.
Aug 14
thumb_up 0
SparkNorkx
Nice art and interesting story. It kinda reminds me of Deadman Wonderland.
Aug 14
thumb_up 0
dddd84187
This story has a very interesting premise and a lot of potential, but the way that it was conveyed was slow and a bit rocky. This story has hope and a lot it can do to grow or even surpass other stories due to it's unique concept, but it needs to avoid typical plot holes that will make it feel very common and uninteresting. Overall, if you don't mind a slower story and want to read something unique, I would recommend reading this series.
Aug 14
thumb_up 0
Jake@シノン教
This manga has a serious topic. What if you know that a newborn child will become a criminal? Does it still deserve to be raised? Or should it be disposed of? This is a very interesting setting and draws the reader right into the story. The art is fine, but it could have been made darker which would fit the topic and setting. At some points the reading flow (the way the panels are placed) are a bit different than usual. However, that is not the reason I only gave 4 out of 5 stars. The reason is that the manga's story is a serious one, but it seems to have some comedic moments making it seem less serious. (This is probably due to the fact that this manga is supposed to be a Shounen manga. This is pretty unfortunate, because of the serious topic that should not be made light of. Seinen would fit so much better. Therefore, 4/5 stars, because I don't think it will become a masterpiece, but just a good and interesting manga.)
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
s8n777
Brave New World manga style. Well not quite that far in the process so that the system is not completely polished. Dystopian future, YA stuff. Art is not bad. First chapter sets up the world's system. With this being a setting you may have gotten over many other titles; You may have had the desire that the characters get a bit more of the spotlight in the first chapter. Might give the next chapter a read if I'm caught up with all my other series.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
gamingwolf97x
Great story and nice art.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
Kurogiku
An exciting story where one's class is decided at birth with the notion that people are innately evil. The art is a little rough at times.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
SuperSaiyaLink
Sinner is a very interesting a exciting story. It makes you wonder who the real sinners are, those deemed innocent by the system or those condemned to live as outcasts.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
roquenigma
Great art. Different type of story
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
weebsucc69
Interesting premise and some exploration of the concept of nature and nurture. I was a little disappointed with the execution of the first few chapters, and the main story of "hack, infiltrate, and collect parts" is boring, but the subplots that appear as it goes on, like the twins and the cake story, are really good. The two main characters are decently developed, but I can't bring myself to care for the other protagonists.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
Luminous
Decent illustration, somewhat original premise, and serviceable exposition make for a good read. The pacing is questionable, though.
Aug 13
thumb_up 0
Syldra
I feel like the prediction idea introduced at the beginning is a bit odd. I'm all for a dark twist in a story, but it almost feels like jumping the gun. Or at least it feels that way since they only used a few pages to provide details. I wish they explained how they determined the morality rate better and how they concluded that it was the best course of action. That said, I like the art style and two main characters at least. When you get a glimpse of their backstories, it's easy to see why they act the way they do.
Aug 12
thumb_up 0
Ininus
Love the plot twist in the begining
Aug 12
thumb_up 0
nicholas19010
Too early to say much about the manga, but it has potential. Will keep reading for now.
Aug 12
thumb_up 0
kevin97kwong
Promising story reminiscent of Psycho-Pass. Concept isn't completely original, but the main characters are interesting enough to keep me reading
Aug 12
thumb_up 0
xLordBaconx
It was really good can't wait to see what happens.
Aug 12
thumb_up 0
Alexander Hunt
Very interesting concept! Excited to see where it goes! Would make a great anime.
Aug 12
thumb_up 1
Stanley Hartono
Interesting concept, an ethically corrupt society that produces citizens who are arguably more evil than sinners themselves. Will read more when I have time.
Aug 12
thumb_up 0